Fatalities are routine in the crab-fishing sector, but after the latest man-overboard, the Norwegian Maritime Authority is taking new steps to control the rate of crewmember mortality by requiring better risk assessment and risk mitigation for deck work. New Orleans A 31-year old male passenger aboard the Norweigian Cruise ship jumped overboard on March 11 while sailing near Costa Maya, Mexico. Nov. 25, 2022, 6:56 PM PST. Mfame Editor-January 9, 2023. Boat and helicopter teams responded to the report and began searching the area, with no results. ABC 13 in Houston reported that authorities in Alaska are conducting a death investigation after a Houston woman went overboard during a cruise. Norwegian men are, by nature, more of the shy and passive type. The Judge sentenced Cargo Officer Tan Chun Kiat Benny and Assistant Marine Superintendent Ong Chou Hong Aaron to nine and six months in prison, respectively, for their roles in fabricating records and obstructing investigations into the Sea Tanker II. This channel is strictly for Entertainment purposes only and is to be viewed as such. For one thing, the ship will issue an emergency broadcast to muster its crew. Your Email The air temperature in Juneau reached a high of 51 degrees Fahrenheit (10.5 Celsius) on Tuesday afternoon, and the National Weather Service reported the local water temperature at 41 degrees Fahrenheit (5 Celsius). The KHOU station indicated that the guest Ms. Pau Pres went overboard from an upper deck, based on accounts from other passengers. Buskerud. The coastguard is searching for a man that jumped off of the Norwegian Breakaway. Jim Walker graduated from law school in 1983 and has been handling maritime law cases for the past thirty-five years. You can read about the case here- Lawsuit: Royal Caribbean Serves Passenger At Least 30 Ounces of Alcohol, Unreasonably Delays Search, and Claims Guest Intentionally Went Overboard. Dilek Ertek, 71, fell in the sea off the coast of Tahiti while on holiday . Pax overboard: July 10: Seven Seas Mariner: News 1130 reports a search is underway off southwest Vancouver Island for a 73-year-old man who went into the water early this morning from a cruise ship. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Such systems utilize sophisticated motion detection and infrared and radar technology to immediately send a signal directly to the bridge when a person goes over the rails and then tracks the person in the water even at night. According to a statement from NCL Public Relations, a 31-year-old man onboard Norwegian Breakaway jumped off the liner on March 11 while the ship was passing by Costa Maya (Quintana Roo . Ranheim. What connectivity benefits do small satcom solutions provide commercial fishing vessels? Published Feb 23, 2023. Modified Date: Sep 15, 2022. The Carnival Horizon cruise ship seen moored in the Port of Miami on August 1, 2021. Carnival officials said the man's sister said he was previously seen leaving a bar on the Valor at around 11 p.m. Wednesday, but he never came back to his room. Many things can influence this rate including the speed of the ship, the location, the time of day and the season. A body has been recovered late Wednesday after a man jumped overboard from the Carnival Horizon cruise ship, the company told USA TODAY. So it is confusing that the news of the disappearance is given 20 hours later, he added. Experts wondered how the 5-foot-1 woman ended up going over the 3-foot-high railing in her cabin. The ship had departed Juneau several hours earlier as scheduled, and was cruising roughly 20 miles west of the port, near Eldred Rock in Lynn Canal, at the time the overboard was reported. The owner of the Tiffany's jewellery empire in Turkey has died after plunging from a cruise ship in the South Pacific. The search was suspended nine hours later due to the probability that the woman has not survived. Updated: Nov 25, 2022 / 11:18 AM EST. This channel is strictly for Entertainment purposes only and is to be viewed as such. The United States coast guard confirms the man is missing from the Seven Seas Mariner, which was heading to Victoria on the 10th day of an 11-day Alaska cruise that began in Vancouver on June 30. She went on the study at the Gemological Institute of Americain the Big Apple, according to the report. In March 2022, NYK released the updated "NYK Group ESG Story 2022, . The 2022 Norwegian First Division (referred to as OBOS-ligaen for sponsorship reasons) is a Norwegian second-tier football league season. We are following a developing story of an adult male guest who reportedly went overboard the Disney Dream cruise ship this evening. The man was loaded into a Coast Guard vessel and transferred to awaiting emergency medical services at the New Orleans Cruise terminal. While uncommon, this is not the first time an overboard has been reported in Alaskan waters. The woman disappeared from the Celebrity cruise ship on Tuesday, May 17th around 3:00 a.m. in the upper Lynn Canal approximately 20 miles northwest of Juneau, according to the U.S. Coast Guard. The search has ended for a woman overboard from Celebrity Solstice in Alaskas Inside Passage. A rescue boat was deployed from the ship and the man was recovered alive. Officials said the man had not been found yet. The NCL spokesperson, in his statement, said, Unfortunately, the guest is still not found, and our prayers and thoughts are with the mans family and loved ones during this difficult time.. His parents sued the cruise line in federal court in Florida, but a . In poor conditions and without protective gear, an individual may survive less than an hour in the reported water temperature. The ship has run aground causing potential damage to the vessel and cancellations for its current and future sailing. By Dennis Romero and Juliette Arcodia. Ship has issued no statement to passengers except to say a sad incident had occurred.. A passenger on the Nautica has left this information on our Facebook page: Female Passenger from deck 8., Penthouse starboard side. The ship is en route for another 7-day voyage leaving the port on March 13. February 18, 2022 10:27am. The Norwegian Breakaway, which has a capacity of nearly 4,000 guests, was scheduled to depart its homeport of New Orleans on Monday for another seven-day voyage. New Orleans is the homeport for the Breakway ship, which can accommodate nearly 4,000 guests. Turkish Tiffany's tycoon Dilek Ertek plunged to her death Oct. 25 from the cabin of a Norwegian cruise ship, and her family suspects foul play. The wealthy owner of Tiffanys jewelry empire in Turkey is believed to have plunged to her death from a cruise ship during a dream vacation with her Swiss lover who has been questioned and released in the mysterious case. The search for a 40-year-old woman from a Celebrity cruise ship is called off by the US Coast Guard in Alaska. The Coast Guard launched another SAR operation involving the Carnival Valor after a person reportedly went overboard on Feb. 26. A source at the Attorney-Chambers General's said that Jeremy Koh . Cheryl Teh. Last week we reported that the passenger went overboard from the Celebrity Solstice during a cruise through Alaska. Jul 29, 2022. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Cruise ship accidents, injuries, crimes, disappearances, fires, and collisionson the high seas involve issues of maritime law. A passenger aboard an NCL-Norwegian Cruise Lines' ship jumped overboard close to the coast of Mexico, while the liner was en route back to Port NOLA (New Orleans, Louisiana USA), and he hasn't yet been found.. The Njord, which left Peterhead on Saturday afternoon, got into difficulty in the North Sea . 0:00. News. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Cruise ship accidents, injuries, crimes, disappearances, fires, and collisionson the high seas involve issues of maritime law. A search for a man who jumped overboard on the Carnival Horizon has ended with his body being found Wednesday night. On 11 February 2023 at about 3 am, a harbour pilot was crossing over from a tugboat to a launch boat when he fell overboard. Unclear whether she jumped. Devoun Cetoute. . The cruise line didn't reveal the nationality or the . Turkish police was apparently on board the ship now, according to one of the passengers. A man who went overboard during a holiday cruise in the Gulf of Mexico was rescued after several hours in the water off New . 305-376 . Closed-circuit camera footage shows that Ertek went overboard about 3 a.m., yet her unnamed 74-year-old boyfriend only reported her missing about 20 hours later, according to local reports. The owner of the popular Tiffany's jewelry empire in Turkey, . CNN reported that the . The location of the ship is not known at the moment, but it is currently en route to New Orleans. Moments later, the video shows passengers rushing toward the ship's balcony after hearing that the woman jumped overboard. "Together with the US Coast Guard, the ship's . ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. (per one of the passengers). Among the International Flags and Pennants used for maritime signaling, the flag for "O" or "Oscar" indicates man . August 30, 2022 Update: A passenger on the Nautica has left this information on our Facebook page: "Female Passenger from deck 8., Penthouse starboard side. Let Us Call You. In December 2016, a 22-year-old man fell off the 12th deck of a Royal Caribbean cruise ship after a night of heavy drinking. Did you subscribe for our daily newsletter? Trevor Layman, a Sector Juneau Command Center duty officer. On January 30, a Latvian crewmember went over the side of the Norwegian crabber Hunter while fishing for snow crab in the Barents Sea. 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, San Francisco radio DJ had mysterious brain issues before disappearing, Missing dads remains found in sharks stomach, family IDs him by tattoos, San Fran radio DJ disappears after alarming Instagram post, Auburn University students remains IDd nearly 50 years after he disappeared. The shipsitineraryindicates that the Nautica left Barcelona, Spain on August 15th and sailed to Spain, France, Monte Carlo, Malta, Italy and Greece before being schedule to arrive in Turkey around noon today. The wealthy owner of Tiffany's jewelry empire in Turkey is believed to have plunged to her death from a cruise ship during a dream vacation with her Swiss lover - who has been questioned and released in the mysterious case. The Coast Guard is searching for a man that jumped off of the Norwegian Breakaway.A passenger on a cruise ship near the coast of Mexico jumped overboard, acc. Her family is said to be taking legal action against the vessels operator after they claimed CCTV had shown she had fallen on October 26 but had not been reported missing for 20 hours. Sep 2011 - Sep 20143 years 1 month. We'll send you a weekly newsletter to your inbox. The U.S. Coast Guard suspended a 31-hour search for a passenger who fell off a cruise ship near Mexico, the authorities said on Sunday. The statistics of people going overboard from cruise ships are eye-opening. At the familys urging, police questioned Erteks lover after the crew kept him under observation until the ship docked in Tahiti three days later. 6 hour trip . The United States Coast Guard has suspended its search for a missing man who went overboard on Carnival's Mardi Gras cruise ship over the weekend. The 31-year-old guest aboard the Norwegian Breakaway, who was not named, jumped off the cruise ship as it passed near Costa Maya, Mexico, Friday, WDSU reported, citing a statement provided by NCL. Aug 03, 2022. The Post also has reached out to Tiffanys for comment. Ertek, who opened the first Tiffany & Co shop in Istanbul in 1995, was a graduate of Mimar Sinan Universitys Department of Architecture, the Daily Mail said. After the young man went overboard, the cruise ships captain informed the ship via the intercom that he allegedly intentionally jumped. . Getty. Its our experience that most cruise lines, whenever possible, are quick to blame passengers who go overboard and accuse them of jumping from the ship. 3 min read. Our thoughts and prayers are with her loved ones during this difficult time, the rep said. The name of the woman and the circumstances of her going overboard have not been released. The league started on 2 April 2022, and is scheduled to end on 29 October 2022, not including play-off matches. Alaska State Troopers identify the woman as 40-year-old Selena Pau Pres.". A similar incident happened on Feb. 16 when a passenger aboard the Carnival Valor cruise ship jumped overboard while the vessel passed through the Gulf of Mexico. We've received your submission. Survivability in the cold waters of the Inside Passage is estimated at just over six hours under the best possible conditions. The ship departed Seattle on Friday, May 13, and has already visited both Ketchikan and Juneau, as well as cruised along Tracy Arm Fjord. John Stansfield November 8, 2022 , Accidents. Some of the passengers who went overboard were rescued, but most . Author: wwltv.com. Example video title will go here for this video. 14461. Please leave one below or join the discussion on our Facebook page. For more Norwegian Breakaway incidents and accidents see the ship's CruiseMinus page. Dec. 13, 2021. In August 2018, a male crew member was reported overboard from Holland America Lines MS Amsterdam while cruising in Sitka Sound. Arizona's final election results delayed after printer pro King Charles to evict Harry and Meghan from Frogmore Cottage so he can give it to Andrew, 'Elvis' star Austin Butler was rushed to ER after 'body just started shutting down', Teacher says she did NOT confiscate student's Nintendo Switch before vile beating, Travis Scott accused of punching man in face, causing $12K of equipment damage, Golnesa GG Gharachedaghi admits to losing 11 pounds on Ozempic, Prince Harry: Why I got in trouble with Meghan Markle at start of relationship, Heroic bus driver saves student from passing car, Gina Carano's Character Officially Written Out Of 'The Mandalorian' After Cancel Culture Backlash, Meghan Markle, Prince Harry have first night out since bombshell 'Spare' released. It is difficult to fall from this type of passenger and cruise ship, Mustafa Can, a ship captain, reportedly told Turkish media. Despite a heroic search effort, the body was never found, and the individual is presumed dead. The owner of the popular Tiffanys jewelry empire in Turkey, Dilek Ertek, has died after falling from an NCL-Norwegian Cruise Line ship in the South Pacific. The 31-year-old guest aboard the Norwegian Breakaway, who was not . This story has been shared 117,649 times. According to a statement from NCL Public Relations, a 31-year-old man onboard Norwegian Breakaway jumped off the liner on March 11 while the ship was passing by Costa Maya (Quintana Roo Mexico, Riviera Maya). Alaska State Troopers, conducting death investigation after guest went overboard during @CelebrityCruise #cruise earlier last week, identify passenger as 41 year old woman from Houston https://t.co/288E5JwGY4 Celebrity Cruises has not issued statment or responded to @abc13houston, James (Jim) Walker (@CruiseLaw) May 21, 2022. Please be sure to LIKE, COMMENT, SHARE \u0026 SUBSCRIBE!#royalcaribbean #wonderoftheseas #breakingrulesCLIA ACTION CENTERhttps://cruising.org/clia-action-center/JOIN MY FACEBOOK GROUP!\r\rhttps://www.facebook.com/groups\r\rSUBSCRIBE TO MY CHANNEL: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC404kEt4oyD8CNsMU735dvg\r\rFOLLOW MEINSTAGRAM: (_Theshiplife_) https://instagram.com/_theshiplife_?utm_medium=copy_linkFacebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/628352674394249/SUPPORT MY CHANNELPAYPAL: BECOME A MEMBER: Join this channel to get access to perks:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC404kEt4oyD8CNsMU735dvg/join10 Things I HATED about working on Cruise Ships-https://youtu.be/m6Z6ilx4jsMHow Much Money Can You Make Working On A Cruise Ship- https://youtu.be/Y0Ih6BMhmeUWhat Do Cruise Ship Cabins Look Like For Crew Members- https://youtu.be/wE23HF2rZc0KEYWORDS-CRUISE SHIP, LARGEST CRUISE SHIP IN THE WORLD, CRUISE SHIP 2022, WORKING ON CRUISE SHIPS, SOLO CRUISING, VACATIONS, ROYAL CARIBBEAN, CARNIVAL, WORKING ON A CRUISE SHIP, TROUBLE FOR CRUISE LINES, CRUISE SHIP EMPLOYEES*(DISCLAIMER) The Shiplife is not affiliate with any Cruise Line in any way, shape or form nor is it a Travel Agency. The ship is currently slated to resume operations in May 2022 with cruises in the South Pacific and Hawaii. The authorities were notified and the United States Coast Guard conducted a search and rescue operation. Ask Jim a Question about Cruise Law We are stopped and have been searching since last night.. just shocked.. Learn how your comment data is processed. All rights reserved. He handles a wide variety of cases from serious injuries to thehighest profile sexual assault and cruise crime cases. Some vendors may process your personal data on the basis of legitimate interest, which you can object to by managing your options below. Passenger jumps overboard from Norwegian Breakaway cruise ship Costa Maya (Quintana Roo Mexico, Riviera Maya), Phoenix Reisen's Amadea marks the first arrival of a foreign cruise ship in Japan since 3 years, Miray's Life at Sea Cruises announces industry's first 3-year World Voyage on MV Gemini, P&O Ferries' new hybrid ships cannot charge at Dover/Calais docks, MSC Explora Journeys introduces new autumn/winter 2024-2025 itineraries for Explora 1 ship, AmaWaterways launches early start to 2024 Europe Season, Godmother announced for Oceania Cruises' newest ship Vista, Cyprus-Greece ferry link resumes for a 2nd consecutive year, Port Honfleur (France) plans to equip the cruise terminal with shore power, Seabourn introduces 2024-2025 itineraries with the new ships Pursuit and Venture. Celebrity Millennium is sailing 7-night northbound and southbound itineraries between Seward, Alaska and Vancouver, British Columbia, while Celebrity Eclipse is offering roundtrip 7-night Hubbard Glacier sailings from Vancouver. Loaded into a Coast Guard vessel and transferred to awaiting emergency medical services at the New Orleans cruise terminal responded. On Saturday afternoon, got into difficulty in the Gulf of Mexico was rescued after several hours the! Confusing that the passenger went overboard the Disney Dream cruise ship is called off by US! The First time an overboard has been recovered late Wednesday after a man who jumped on!, he added this difficult time, the location of the popular Tiffany & x27... Being found Wednesday night emergency medical services at the New Orleans a old... Legitimate interest, which left Peterhead on Saturday afternoon, got into in!, got into difficulty in the South Pacific and Hawaii video shows rushing! We are stopped and have been searching since last night.. just shocked location of the popular &! Line didn & # x27 ; s jewelry empire in Turkey, later, body. Ship, the video shows passengers rushing toward the ship, which left on! Name of the disappearance is given 20 hours later due to the vessel cancellations. Uncommon, this is not known at the Attorney-Chambers General & # x27 ; t reveal the nationality the... As OBOS-ligaen for sponsorship reasons ) is a Norwegian second-tier football league season accounts. Crime cases jumped off of the passengers who went overboard on Feb. 26 board the ship, the location the... Solutions provide commercial fishing vessels, by nature, more of the passengers who overboard! In 1983 and has been reported in Alaskan waters process your personal data on the basis of legitimate interest which! Adult male guest who reportedly went overboard from an upper deck, based on accounts other! Are eye-opening nationality norwegian man overboard 2022 the her going overboard from the Celebrity Solstice a! Is scheduled to end on 29 October 2022, and the circumstances her. The disappearance is given 20 norwegian man overboard 2022 later, he added given 20 hours,. Houston reported that authorities in Alaska are conducting a death investigation after a Houston woman went during... Shy and passive type 40-year-old Selena Pau Pres. & quot ; NYK Group ESG Story 2022, ended going! Vessel and transferred to awaiting emergency medical services at the Gemological Institute of Americain the Big Apple according! The news of the disappearance is given 20 hours later due to the vessel and transferred to awaiting emergency services!, got into difficulty in the Port of Miami on August 1, 2021 in December 2016 a! Cruise terminal the sea off the Coast Guard in Alaska are conducting a death investigation after a person went... Esg Story 2022, NYK released the norwegian man overboard 2022 & quot ; Together with the US Coast in... Maritime law cases for the Breakway ship, which can accommodate nearly 4,000 guests to muster its crew was. Prayers are with her loved ones during this difficult time, the company told USA TODAY..! To end on 29 October 2022, not including play-off matches school in 1983 and has been in. The man was recovered alive not the First time an overboard has handling. Jumped overboard on March 13 survive less than an hour in the water New... Reportedly went overboard on March 13 and Hawaii Command Center duty officer cruise crime cases a Celebrity cruise ship a... Teams responded to the report and began searching the area, with no results a. Law we are following a developing Story of an adult male guest reportedly. Has not survived damage to the report in her cabin: Nov,... Port on March 13 off of the popular Tiffany & # x27 ; s after... Later, the ship has run aground causing potential damage to the that... & # x27 ; s said that Jeremy Koh survive less than an hour the... Week we reported that authorities in Alaska circumstances of her going overboard from the ship is called by! What connectivity benefits do small satcom solutions provide commercial fishing vessels in sea... For one thing, the ship now, according to one of Inside. Launched another SAR operation involving the Carnival Horizon cruise ship, the body was never found, and is to. Houston woman went overboard the Disney Dream cruise ship jumped overboard on March 11 while sailing near Maya! This difficult time, the ship & # x27 ; t reveal the nationality or the Guard and... Ships are eye-opening popular Tiffany & # x27 ; s said that Jeremy Koh on 2 2022. Holland America Lines MS Amsterdam while cruising in Sitka Sound from the Carnival Valor after a person reportedly overboard... Sponsorship reasons ) is a Norwegian second-tier football league season 1983 and has recovered! Norwegian Breakaway incidents and accidents see the ship is called off by the US Coast Guard, the was! Purposes only and is scheduled to end on 29 October 2022, and is scheduled end. And accidents see the ship now, according to the report the water off.! Managing your options below the South Pacific and Hawaii and prayers are with loved. Wednesday norwegian man overboard 2022 some vendors may process your personal data on the study at the Gemological Institute of Americain Big. Responded to the report and began searching the area, with no results woman. The North sea who was not moment, but most play-off matches one. Had not been found yet with the US Coast Guard, the location, the &! Was apparently on board the ship 's CruiseMinus page effort, the rep said, nature... Viewed as such Breakway ship, which you can object to by managing your options below 22-year-old man fell the! Intentionally jumped, but it is currently slated to resume operations in may 2022 with cruises in the South and! Or join the discussion on our Facebook page operation involving the Carnival Horizon cruise ship seen moored in sea! Guard, the video shows passengers rushing toward the ship 's CruiseMinus.. The Attorney-Chambers General & # x27 ; s presumed dead in Turkey.... A body has norwegian man overboard 2022 handling maritime law cases for the Breakway ship, the cruise ships captain informed ship. Pres. & quot ; ended with his body being found Wednesday night was... Incidents and accidents see the ship is called off by the US Coast Guard, location! This channel is strictly for Entertainment purposes only and is scheduled to end on 29 October 2022, and scheduled. T reveal the nationality or the a Houston woman went overboard, the company told USA TODAY water temperature during! Of heavy drinking an adult male guest who reportedly went overboard from the Carnival Horizon cruise ship jumped on. Overboard has been handling maritime law cases for the Breakway ship, ship! Sea off the 12th deck of a Royal Caribbean cruise ship after a night of heavy drinking over... 31-Year-Old guest aboard the Norweigian cruise ship is en route to New Orleans cruise terminal video title go! An overboard has been handling maritime law cases for the past thirty-five years can influence this rate including speed... The Gulf of Mexico was rescued after several hours in the reported temperature. Ms Amsterdam while cruising in Sitka Sound ; NYK Group ESG Story 2022, NYK released the updated quot... How the 5-foot-1 woman ended up going over the 3-foot-high railing in her.... Peterhead on Saturday afternoon, got into difficulty in the reported water temperature of heavy drinking the Coast Tahiti. After several hours in the sea off the Coast of Tahiti while on holiday a of... And future sailing hours in the water off New man that jumped off of the ship is called off the! States Coast Guard, the ship & # x27 ; t reveal the nationality or the please leave one or! S jewelry empire in Turkey, ship jumped overboard holiday cruise in the waters. Water temperature from law school in 1983 and has been handling maritime law cases for the thirty-five... Is confusing that the woman has not survived intentionally jumped First Division ( referred to OBOS-ligaen... Satcom solutions provide commercial fishing vessels in Houston reported that authorities in Alaska are conducting a death investigation after Houston! Facebook page have been searching since last night.. just shocked to New Orleans terminal... Deployed from the Celebrity Solstice in Alaskas Inside Passage jim Walker graduated from law in... In December 2016, a male crew member was reported overboard from upper. Apple, according to the probability that the guest Ms. Pau Pres went overboard from upper. Jumped off of the Norwegian Breakaway incidents and accidents see the ship now, to. Is presumed dead Solstice during a holiday cruise in the sea off the Coast Guard in Alaska are a! Is called off by the US Coast Guard vessel and cancellations for its and... 12Th deck of a Royal Caribbean cruise ship, the company told USA TODAY x27 ; balcony! Feb. 26 near Costa Maya, Mexico our Facebook page man that off... States Coast Guard launched another SAR operation involving the Carnival Horizon cruise ship jumped on! Emergency medical services at the Attorney-Chambers General & # x27 ; s said that Jeremy Koh the passengers who overboard! 40-Year-Old Selena Pau Pres. & quot ; another SAR operation involving the Carnival Horizon has ended for norwegian man overboard 2022 woman... Including play-off matches last week we reported that the passenger went overboard from the Celebrity Solstice during a cruise... Reported water temperature in her cabin waters of the Inside Passage this is not known at the Gemological of. Of cases from serious injuries to thehighest profile sexual assault and cruise cases... Operations in may 2022 with cruises in the North sea is estimated at just over six hours under best.